8

What is the best setting on iPad for reading eBooks

This question, in its current form, asks in both the title and the body what the best iPad settings are to reduce vision strain.

Note: I'm keeping this question purposefully minimal so that my own bias is contained only within my answer, to help keep the voting clear.

7

No, this question should not be on-topic, even though it deals with the physical problem of vision.

Yes, the scope of Lifehacks is about physical problems, but it's also about lifehacks, not software configuration. The question specifically is asking for iPad settings to reduce eye strain... it is not looking for general eye-strain reduction advice. Just because eye strain is a physical problem doesn't mean that the specifically-worded question here that involves eye strain is on-topic.

It's a question asking about how to configure a tool to do the job it's meant to do. It's not a question asking for an unconventional solution to a physical problem.... in fact, the question specifically has narrowed the scope of answers to just the conventional... adjusting the iPad settings. That is not what this site is about.

There probably is an on-topic version of this question that expands the scope to cover more than just iPad settings. However, I don't believe it's in our best interest to just ignore the restrictions of a question and assume the more general scope, as Mooseman did in his answer to the question. There's the whole idea of XY Problem where you want to solve the problem they're really having, and not the one they're asking about, but I don't think that's what we're dealing with here. Changing the iPad settings might be a perfectly acceptable way of reducing eye strain. Changing the scope of the question for them wouldn't be solving the XY problem... it'd simply be changing the question so that it fits better what we want on our site. That seems inappropriate.

  • 3
    Changing the question so that it fits better what we want on our site is perfectly appropriate and encouraged, when the original question is not suitable for the site. – Gilles Mar 16 '15 at 19:51
  • I had many comments explaining why I don't think the edit on the user's behalf was a good idea on Mooseman's now-deleted answer to this question. They amounted to "If the user really was just after specifically iPad settings, as they say in their question, changing their question to a general one about eye strain, rather than directing them to a site like AskDifferent, serves us rather than the user. We're here to help users get answers to their questions, not change their questions to ones they may not care about so that we can grow our site. – Sterno Mar 18 '15 at 12:35
  • That said, the edit on the user's behalf was a minor quibble that I wouldn't have been all that bothered by, compared to leaving it, in it's original form, on-topic. – Sterno Mar 18 '15 at 12:35

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .