This image sums it up:
You can see that we have 6 people voted - 3 for leave open and 3 for close. I voted to Leave Open because I believe it is clear what it's asking.
If the review queue is that subjective this site still has a lot of problems - and this is not a one off (click the image to link to review):
I don't know the answers, but I'm hoping there is a solution for this site... We need a way to know, definitively what should be closed and what shouldn't, and we need it quickly.