2

Open a suitcase with a numeric lock when you forgot the key code this question of mine has been closed now for the second time, this is not a rant, so please read the question as objectively as possible.

The reason I decided to post here was because I feel that this has been put on hold for two invalid reasons. First it was felt this is off topic, and then reopened. It was also felt that it was too broad, so I narrowed it to just focus on suitcases, but this is now been closed as too broad even now, I just feel that the real reason is something else.

Specifically I want to ensure that the community here is aware of the implications of such questions being deleted. If how to open a locked suitcase is too broad, that too with a specific type of lock (numeric) then I guess there is something wrong with the definition.

To make my point I would like to equate this SE to a computer hacking SE, would how to break a specific weak password (lets say Dictionary words) be too broad there? Again I am not specifically worried about my question being closed or deleted or whatever, but we cannot assume that this is dangerous and close the question for one reason or the other.

There are other questions too, like How can I test for electrical current through bare wires without a meter? where people just become afraid of something and vote for a close, this itself I think is a very dangerous trend that needs to be avoided if this site were to live. Some lifehacks will be dangerous and we have to accept it, take precautions rather than closing our eyes to it.

| |
4

I think this question is too broad.

There are many (!) different locks, many of which have different options on how you could open them without destroying them. Without knowing the specific branch of lock in use there is no chance to answer this without guessing.

So this question is not answerable within a few paragraphs, answers that aim at completeness need to be overly long. Thats the very definition of too broad.

| |
  • Point taken, question has been modified – skv Dec 12 '14 at 11:35
  • 2
    @skv That image helped a lot. I had something completely different in my mind. – Angelo Fuchs Dec 12 '14 at 12:05
  • 1
    @skv Agreed, the image is totally different than what I imagined. From the text "commonly found in suitcases", I thought you meant mainly built-in locks, more like this one (see my comment about opening one with a screwdriver, etc). The edit has clarified that. – TIO Begs Dec 12 '14 at 14:01

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .